Comments on: Do you think that slavery is justified under such conditions? http://www.equipmentindustrialmachinery.com/military/do-you-think-that-slavery-is-justified-under-such-conditions/ Ground Engaging Equipment Fri, 18 May 2012 21:04:52 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.7 hourly 1 By: Sean M http://www.equipmentindustrialmachinery.com/military/do-you-think-that-slavery-is-justified-under-such-conditions/comment-page-1/#comment-608 Sean M Tue, 06 Jan 2009 14:57:25 +0000 http://www.equipmentindustrialmachinery.com/military/do-you-think-that-slavery-is-justified-under-such-conditions/#comment-608 Iraq is tough question because we go back and forth on who is a POW and then whether they can have POW rights. Further, the nature of a POW implies they have a nation that owns them so to speak. So during WWII US POWs in Japan and Japanese POWs in the US were had a country asking for their return. In this case no-one seems to be asking as a sovreign nation for their children back. Yes, POWs can be used to rebuild. Yes, POWs have rights, and benefits. No, they cannot be called POWs for work and not POWs for right and benefits. In 50 years we'll get to read and live these experiences and decisions in a Musuem as our US Senate will probably one day issue an apology like they do all so sadly often in hindsite. But until then we will do and then decide later to judge ourselves. Iraq is tough question because we go back and forth on who is a POW and then whether they can have POW rights. Further, the nature of a POW implies they have a nation that owns them so to speak. So during WWII US POWs in Japan and Japanese POWs in the US were had a country asking for their return. In this case no-one seems to be asking as a sovreign nation for their children back.

Yes, POWs can be used to rebuild. Yes, POWs have rights, and benefits. No, they cannot be called POWs for work and not POWs for right and benefits.

In 50 years we’ll get to read and live these experiences and decisions in a Musuem as our US Senate will probably one day issue an apology like they do all so sadly often in hindsite. But until then we will do and then decide later to judge ourselves.

]]> By: joshbl74 http://www.equipmentindustrialmachinery.com/military/do-you-think-that-slavery-is-justified-under-such-conditions/comment-page-1/#comment-607 joshbl74 Mon, 05 Jan 2009 23:11:55 +0000 http://www.equipmentindustrialmachinery.com/military/do-you-think-that-slavery-is-justified-under-such-conditions/#comment-607 Justified?? Maybe not. It's really just revenge. That's different than justice. The POW's are just soldiers. Soldiers don't decide to invade countries. Soldiers just go where ordered and kill the enemy as ordered. If you had actual criminals and you wanted to force them to work then fine. It's punishment. I don't think soldiers deserve to be punished for doing thier jobs. You kill them as quick as you can until they surrender, then you hold them on the side till the fighting is over. I respect anyone who will take up arms in the name of thier homeland, even if they are my enemy. I want to make the enemy surrender (unsually by killing all his friends). Forced labor would discourage surrender and prolong the battle. Thats not good for anyone. Justified?? Maybe not. It’s really just revenge. That’s different than justice. The POW’s are just soldiers. Soldiers don’t decide to invade countries. Soldiers just go where ordered and kill the enemy as ordered. If you had actual criminals and you wanted to force them to work then fine. It’s punishment. I don’t think soldiers deserve to be punished for doing thier jobs. You kill them as quick as you can until they surrender, then you hold them on the side till the fighting is over. I respect anyone who will take up arms in the name of thier homeland, even if they are my enemy. I want to make the enemy surrender (unsually by killing all his friends). Forced labor would discourage surrender and prolong the battle. Thats not good for anyone.

]]> By: Sherilynne B http://www.equipmentindustrialmachinery.com/military/do-you-think-that-slavery-is-justified-under-such-conditions/comment-page-1/#comment-606 Sherilynne B Sun, 04 Jan 2009 10:35:10 +0000 http://www.equipmentindustrialmachinery.com/military/do-you-think-that-slavery-is-justified-under-such-conditions/#comment-606 I don't think that slavery is ever justified. I don’t think that slavery is ever justified.

]]> By: China Rockz http://www.equipmentindustrialmachinery.com/military/do-you-think-that-slavery-is-justified-under-such-conditions/comment-page-1/#comment-605 China Rockz Sat, 03 Jan 2009 02:06:33 +0000 http://www.equipmentindustrialmachinery.com/military/do-you-think-that-slavery-is-justified-under-such-conditions/#comment-605 Its very much justified. And I would love question the wits of the invaders in the first place. Its very much justified. And I would love question the wits of the invaders in the first place.

]]> By: fateridder http://www.equipmentindustrialmachinery.com/military/do-you-think-that-slavery-is-justified-under-such-conditions/comment-page-1/#comment-604 fateridder Wed, 31 Dec 2008 09:49:34 +0000 http://www.equipmentindustrialmachinery.com/military/do-you-think-that-slavery-is-justified-under-such-conditions/#comment-604 I know this might seem odd , but I have always thought the US should of taken the Japanese at Hiroshima and Nagasaki as slaves , after all they were going to be dead anyway at least they could of lived . I know this might seem odd , but I have always thought the US should of taken the Japanese at Hiroshima and Nagasaki as slaves , after all they were going to be dead anyway at least they could of lived .

]]> By: frosty62 http://www.equipmentindustrialmachinery.com/military/do-you-think-that-slavery-is-justified-under-such-conditions/comment-page-1/#comment-603 frosty62 Tue, 30 Dec 2008 22:01:51 +0000 http://www.equipmentindustrialmachinery.com/military/do-you-think-that-slavery-is-justified-under-such-conditions/#comment-603 I think this is the same as repaying a debt to society. I mean they are prisoners not innocent people foced into slavery right? I think this is the same as repaying a debt to society. I mean they are prisoners not innocent people foced into slavery right?

]]> By: pensterx http://www.equipmentindustrialmachinery.com/military/do-you-think-that-slavery-is-justified-under-such-conditions/comment-page-1/#comment-602 pensterx Sat, 27 Dec 2008 21:26:28 +0000 http://www.equipmentindustrialmachinery.com/military/do-you-think-that-slavery-is-justified-under-such-conditions/#comment-602 After the second world war many German POWs were forced to rebuild roads, cities, etc in Russia. After the second world war many German POWs were forced to rebuild roads, cities, etc in Russia.

]]> By: Robin C http://www.equipmentindustrialmachinery.com/military/do-you-think-that-slavery-is-justified-under-such-conditions/comment-page-1/#comment-601 Robin C Sat, 27 Dec 2008 02:19:31 +0000 http://www.equipmentindustrialmachinery.com/military/do-you-think-that-slavery-is-justified-under-such-conditions/#comment-601 sounds somewhat barbaric to me..i mean that would be like saying ok...i made a mess..now u clean it up..don't think so..i don't believe in slavery under any conditions sounds somewhat barbaric to me..i mean that would be like saying ok…i made a mess..now u clean it up..don’t think so..i don’t believe in slavery under any conditions

]]> By: oldhippypaul http://www.equipmentindustrialmachinery.com/military/do-you-think-that-slavery-is-justified-under-such-conditions/comment-page-1/#comment-600 oldhippypaul Thu, 25 Dec 2008 07:23:06 +0000 http://www.equipmentindustrialmachinery.com/military/do-you-think-that-slavery-is-justified-under-such-conditions/#comment-600 It is probably justified but i question how functional it would be. A few members of the invading force would be of course engineer types but the average grunt could do little more than fetch and carry on a construction site. Modern construction requires highly skilled labor which you are not going to find among the prisoners of even a technological nation like ours. I know I would have been worthless at rebuilding anything. I suspect that the troops of most of the worlds powers would be even worse. Better I think to make the invading power pay for a multinational to do the job right. It is probably justified but i question how functional it would be. A few members of the invading force would be of course engineer types but the average grunt could do little more than fetch and carry on a construction site. Modern construction requires highly skilled labor which you are not going to find among the prisoners of even a technological nation like ours. I know I would have been worthless at rebuilding anything. I suspect that the troops of most of the worlds powers would be even worse. Better I think to make the invading power pay for a multinational to do the job right.

]]> By: Otis http://www.equipmentindustrialmachinery.com/military/do-you-think-that-slavery-is-justified-under-such-conditions/comment-page-1/#comment-599 Otis Mon, 22 Dec 2008 22:48:15 +0000 http://www.equipmentindustrialmachinery.com/military/do-you-think-that-slavery-is-justified-under-such-conditions/#comment-599 I do not believe that this would justify slavery, as nothing would, because it is still trying to own somebody. According ot the Geneva convention you are not to be harmed, and cannot be forced to work, though if you are a chaplain or medical personnel. Both sides have caused damage to the area, so both sides can rebuild, but nobody should be enslaved and forced to work jobs they do not know to make one society better. That would just be that much more motivation for one country to invade another. Sample, if the invasion of Saudi Arabia would have went through, all those people would have had to rebuild oilrigs so others could profit from it.I think not. Though most countries will not play by our rules and do use their POWs as slave labor, I believe that it is totally wrong. I do not believe that this would justify slavery, as nothing would, because it is still trying to own somebody. According ot the Geneva convention you are not to be harmed, and cannot be forced to work, though if you are a chaplain or medical personnel. Both sides have caused damage to the area, so both sides can rebuild, but nobody should be enslaved and forced to work jobs they do not know to make one society better. That would just be that much more motivation for one country to invade another. Sample, if the invasion of Saudi Arabia would have went through, all those people would have had to rebuild oilrigs so others could profit from it.I think not. Though most countries will not play by our rules and do use their POWs as slave labor, I believe that it is totally wrong.

]]>